On September 11th in 2001 my first-born, Annie, turned 16. We had tried to plan something special for weeks. It was, after all, a 16th birthday and in the US it is something of a milestone. Dreadful reality shows like “My Sweet Sixteen” are indulgent, ostentatious, and narcissistic tributes to the importance this birthday plays in the United States.
“Do we get a limo?” I said to my husband worried that I didn’t know how to honor her properly. He looked at me in disbelief and didn’t even have to think about it. “Well, at a cost of $100 an hour I would say – No!” he said emphatically. In the end we decided to have balloons delivered to her high school and a small dinner with two of her friends before a larger party planned for a weekend.
On 9/11 at 8:46 am, on a cloudless day with bright blue sky, United Airlines Flight 11 flew into the first tower followed by a second attack 7 minutes later. All of us know the results. It was, and is, a tragedy and the world gathered in mourning for those killed.
In our family there was a problem. This day had always been a day of rejoicing and celebration. It was the day that in Chicago in 1985 I delivered a bundle of beauty called Annie. Every year was another chance to celebrate all of her life – her talents, her joys, her personality. It hardly seemed fair that terrorists could co-opt this day forever so that we could never again rejoice on the day of her birth. How many other babies were born that day? How many people in the past could have anticipated that their wedding anniversary would fall on a day that terrorists would choose to blow up buildings and destroy life?
Every year I think about this. I think about how I feel guilty celebrating and I feel anger about the domino affect of evil. In this case how it didn’t just affect those killed and the families of those killed but a far bigger circle. Evil permeates like volcanic ash spreading around for miles beyond the volcano and affecting people seemingly far removed from the actual act.
I also think about how life is full of moments like these, where one person is weeping while the next is laughing. Where at the very moment a family is rejoicing at the birth of a baby, someone else is weeping as they watch their loved one take a last breath.
September 11th will always be Annie’s birthday. For 16 years before 9/11 it was her birthday and it still is. It also happens to be a day chosen by people with evil intent to destroy life. Because those two fall on the same day I am acutely aware of the One who brings life and the one who brings death and find both comfort and solution in these words:
The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full. – John 10:10
I wrote a blog post a while back about being capable of complexity and celebrating a daughter’s life while paying tribute to lives that were lost seems to fit in the “capable of complexity” category. I won’t be posting on 9/11 – there will be millions of news articles, posts, commentaries and they will be far better on analyzing events from 10 years ago and reactions from today. But I will say that I wish my daughter a happy and joy-filled birthday, even as I think back on the sadness and devastation of that day 10 years ago, when evil seemed, for a time, to have won.
Discover more from Marilyn R. Gardner
Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.
Marilyn R. Gardner 
Happy Belated to your Annie. My supervisor and I were talking about this particular topic on 9/11. About how some born on that day, even being born that day of this year have such an event associated with their life. However it is to be, I appreciate your perspective on it and your quote shared. Thank you. And again, I hope Annie celebrated in full positivity and happiness. Happy Birthday!!!
LikeLike
Thank you so much for this message! It’s so true of any catastrophic events isn’t it?
LikeLike
A very happy birthday to Annie. Annie always seems to me to be a bringer of light and hope and understanding. I have never met her but learnt to respect and admire her through your blog, for I did begin reading your blog after the problems began in Egypt.
LikeLike
Thank you Pari … and here’s a surprise! She’s coming back! She’ll be staying with us for a few months as she looks for a job. Looking forward to having her!
LikeLike
Reblogged this on communicating.across.boundaries and commented:
I wrote a post called “Outsiders” today and will still leave that up – I wanted also to repost this article I wrote last year. Thank you for reading!
LikeLike
Thanks to everyone for your wishes and for getting the complexity of the day, a time to rejoice and a time to mourn!
LikeLike
wow, that’s a hard one.
LikeLike
While also wishing Annie a lovely birthday, we are reminded of your inspiring post “with a spoon full of sugar”. May Annie have a spoon full of sugar sprinkled throughout her birthyear to make it especially beautiful.
Petra and Jacqueline
LikeLike
I had a friend at primary school whose birthday was also on September 11th – it was her eleventh birthday in 2001. We don’t really speak anymore, but I still think of her on every September 11th that passes, and hope that she’s not reading the newspapers or watching telly or listening to the radio, but is celebrating somewhere! Happy birthday to Annie :)
LikeLike
I wish your daughter a very Happy Birthday!
I have often wondered how people with birthdays and anniversaries feel about sharing their day NOW with this tragedy. Like you said, it seems rather unfair but also like you said, at any time in the world, one person will be laughing while another one is weeping….While 9/11 will be a day forever for the world to remember, I see no reason why it can’t also be a day to celebrate the ones who survived, the ones who were heros, and the fact that we didn’t crumble but held up through adversity.
LikeLike
Aww, I wish your daughter a very Happy Birthday. xx
LikeLike
Happy 26th Birthday Annie! It’s a bright light to celebrate a birthday on a tragic day. I’m sure it makes the day even brighter.
LikeLike
Happy birthday to your daughter! I have a friend whose birthday is also on the 11th. It definitely comes with its stigma. But i hope she does have an amazing day!
All the best
:)
LikeLike
A Very Happy Birthday to Annie. Positive, beautiful, caring loving, pure, lives like hers have to be celebrated.
LikeLike
Ah, yes. I will celebrate Annie as well on Sunday. Maybe I’ll even mention her. I’ll most definitely find a way to have some Sushi! Thanks for bringing such courageous joy into the world. You and Cliff have a gift for delightful children – thanks be to God!
LikeLike
Happy Birthday to Annie! Maybe having good things happen on a tragic day is part of how good triumphs over evil. Annie’s birthdate was chosen by the Whose foreknowledge never overlooks anything. I appreciate your sensitivity to the matter, but please celebrate on!
LikeLike