I see the village in my mind’s eye: There is an open courtyard with a common sitting area where low charpais, covered with beautiful and colorful quilts, are filled with women and children. Women rule this courtyard! They are in charge and everyone knows it.
Off to the side is the pump, surrounded by a low wall for a measure of privacy. Children and moms surround the pump and laughter and talk are loud. They are speaking village – what’s the price of onions, whose husband has gone to Peshawar for work, why Sadia’s curry isn’t as good as Fatima’s, who’s pregnant, who wants to be pregnant, who’s engaged. Talking village – village stories and village life. There is the smell of curry, onions, and hot spices permeating the village air. There are cow pies on the outside mud walls; there is smoke from the wood fire; there are chapattis baking, and small silver dishes at the ready for food.
The men are nearby in their own gathering space. A space close by and for men alone but who cares? It’s the women’s area that is alive with activity, with life, with color.
Just one click – and chaos ensues. The baby that was toddling around with a naked bottom, a tawees (amulet) with verses of the Koran around his neck, is suddenly screaming and a mom is rushing to pick him up while yelling to her other children to gather. The curry and chapattis are forgotten – who cares about food when you’ve tasted fear and just the taste has filled you to suffocation.
The chaos comes from an attack drone targeted specifically to this area in Pakistan that borders Afghanistan. The controls sit in a sterile room, far removed from faces and places. The target shows up on a computer screen, much like a video game. All it takes is one click.
Just one click to obliterate life.
Just one click to show who’s the boss.
Just one click to be declared the winner.
Just one click and then a coffee break.
Just one click….
Although it is the men’s area that is hit, shrapnel flies as does mortar, brick, death, anger, and sorrow. What doesn’t fly is the terror and what it feels like to grab your children and run. That sits deep in the psyche and affects all of life for years to come.
In a decade of drone use, 95% of all drone attacks have occurred in Pakistan. 95% of 300 drone attacks. They have killed over 2000 militants and we don’t have a number of civilians. Just one click. No numbers. No accountability. That means that 95% of the unknown number of civilians were from Pakistan. It’s elementary school math.
Attack drones in the future will be “cheaper, smaller, faster, stealthier, more lethal, and more autonomous, it is harder to imagine what they won’t do than what they will. Whatever limits drones face will be imposed by us humans — not technology.” Micah Zenko from Foreign Policy Magazine Mar/April 2012.
Any country has a right to defend itself from terror attacks. But it must do so with care, with research into minimizing the so-called “collateral damage” factor. It must also do so with accountability and understanding that collateral damage can lead to future, angry aggression.
The question is this: Does the use of attack drones really make the U.S. safer?
I fear that our love for technology and unmanned aerial vehicles will overlook the obvious (and not so obvious) problems from this type of warfare. Are these drones really “surgically precise” as the narrative would have us believe?
An independent research study “Living Under Drones” produced by International Human Rights and Conflict Resolution Clinic of Stanford Law School (Stanford Clinic) and the Global Justice Clinic at New York University School of Law (NYU Clinic) says this: “Counterproductive’ drone war “terrorizes” civilians in Pakistan. The drone war has given rise to “anxiety and psychological trauma among civilian communities”
This is the first report of this type that I am aware of and there is a need for more independent reports, reports based on neither bias nor drama. With reports comes greater knowledge around the where, how, and why of attack drones. Theoretically taxpayers can ask for that kind of accountability.
Is it that we don’t think about accountability because it’s “just Pakistan”. Do people honestly care about this small and often struggling country? I come from a tribe of people who care – but we are unusual in our backgrounds and have had the privilege of experiencing Pakistan as our adopted home.
Stories like that of Malala Yousafzai help give a human face to Pakistan, but we are a long way from seeing Pakistan as a place that has a face worth protecting. Are we willing to commit to understanding more about attack drone use, and speaking out on this subject as we learn more?
As someone who sees all life as precious, not just American lives, I write this post and ask these questions. What do you think?
20 thoughts on “Just One Click”
Can it be right to kill another person whether by knife,bullet or drone?
is the command of Jesus to love our enemies really so unrealistic?
Is what we are doing now really workIng?
Shivers, you brought that to life Marilyn. We so rarely hear about drones in the media our stop to really think about what it would be lille to be a victim of one divorced from emotion click. Did you see the link to the triptych photographs of soldiers I posted on my page the other day?
I didn’t see those Sophie! I guess I was too busy wanting the recipe for Russian fudge – haha! Going back right now to take a look. Thanks too for this comment. It came on me like a virus the other day when I thought about the women, children, and villages that are affected.
I very much appreciate “Marilyn’s Mom” wisdom. And I agree with your overall point very much Marilyn. I think drones are an insidious extension of war.
“Insidious extension of war” so well said. I appreciated my mom’s wisdom as well :)
I didn’t mean to sign in as Anonymous, previously, dear Marilyn. Did you hear the report from Yemen on NPR yesterday? Hundreds of drones have been used to try to kill approximately 15 Al Queda leaders there. It’s a way to be at war with Al Queda without being at war with Yemen itself, but I still hate it.
You are right on target (pun intended). Thank you for voicing these truths so eloquently.
Thank you – this one has been on my heart for some time…..I just can’t imagine what it’s like.
I recently talked with a man whose job in the war was not to click the button, but to decide which sites to bomb. When I asked him how he, as a Christian, dealt with the possible uncertainty of choosing the wrong place and injuring civilians, he answered that he never made mistakes. Maybe he personally never did make mistakes, but then again, how could he possible know since he was sitting hundreds of miles away from the place he had just ordered to be bombed? It is so tempting to rely on this technology and not put our soldiers in harm’s way, but the long-term results are devastating, to both the civilian populations who live in terror of being bombed and us who live with the increasing hatred of our enemies who can’t possibly compete with our technology.
What a tough conversation to have. I can imagine what you must have been feeling. Also – the mistake statement feels painfully arrogant to me…..Ouch. I have come to love getting your perspective through these comment Anne so thank you.
I wasn’t a conversation, but a quick question. Although I’m deeply troubled by the use of drones, this man didn’t make the decision to use them, but carried out orders. I don’t want to blame soldiers or make them feel (possibly) unnecessarily guilty, but wish that military leaders would rethink this policy.
You preach it, girl! Another thing we need to remember is that drone technology is not limited to us in the west. What we do to others, will soon come back on our own innocents. The next 9/11 could be accomplished with someone else’s drone. It makes me really sad that we, who condemn terrorism, are “terrorizing civilians in Pakistan.”
Oh Mom – I loved this comment SO much. I almost sent the post to you before I published it because I needed your assurance that it was okay….thank you :)